Album Review: the xx – I See You

By on Friday, 27th January 2017 at 12:00 pm

the xx I See You coverIf a new band with a wildly successful debut album falls victim to the so-called “sophomore slump” with their second release, then their third album is inevitably viewed as a comeback effort of sorts. Such has apparently been the case with London indie pop trio the xx, who recently released ‘I See You’, the follow up to their 2009 debut ‘xx’ and 2012 sophomore LP ‘Coexist’.

For the xx, album number three came after a slight detour. The year 2015 saw band member Jamie xx (aka Jamie Smith) put out a solo album titled ‘In Colour’, which our own editor Mary described as “polarising” in her essay from June of that year. ‘In Colour’ wasn’t a complete separation for Jamie xx and his bandmates (the xx co-lead singer Romy Madley-Croft contributed vocals), and as far as sonic colour is concerned, ‘I See You’ is similarly entwined with Smith’s solo work.

The brighter-than-expected overall tone colour of ‘I See You’ leans heavily on Smith’s electro-dance production talents throughout the album. This is not to say that the xx have delved into sunny-sweet pop, only that they’ve lightened things up a bit, and added some texture as well. Album opener ‘Dangerous’ is a prime example, starting off with a chorus of brass and bouncing steadily along to Smith’s beat-driven shuffle. The vocal lines provided by Madley-Croft and Oliver Sims are relegated to secondary status behind the bold statements made in the instrumental arrangement.

Sims and Madley-Croft have their moment soon enough in second track and recent single ‘Say Something Loving’. Their voices are perhaps nothing special individually, but the interplay between them as they trade lyrical lines is sinuous and smooth. The song’s chorus lyrics evolve with each repetition, and both singers hit the emotional target as muted cynicism (“say something loving / I just don’t remember the thrill of affection”) becomes fluttering hope (“you say something loving / it’s so overwhelming, the thrill of affection”) and vulnerable self-expression (“I say something loving / I can’t hold it inside, the thrill of affection”).


The middle of the album becomes a bit wrapped up in its own dark, downtempo production vibe, but while the songs run together, there are still a few moments of brilliance. Sims’s voice is subtle and smooth against the sharp-edged backdrop of Smith’s synths in ‘A Violent Noise’, while Madley-Croft’s vocals in ‘Performance’ are poignantly fragile, laid over a stark, strikingly minimalist instrumental setting.

The album’s lead single ‘On Hold’, featured by editor Mary in this past In the Post, was chosen for good reason. It’s really the only song on the album with a distinct pop hook. While certainly not upbeat, it does pick up the rhythmic pace a little bit, and it allows the album to rebuild some of the momentum lost in the middle section. ‘I Dare You’ has a similar rhythmic energy and radio-friendly quality, and Madley-Croft’s lead vocal in the lines “I’ve been a romantic for so long / all I’ve ever heard are love songs” is as enticing here as it was in the album’s opening tracks. But it’s Smith, in the end, who has the figurative last word in the dark and shadowy final track ‘Test Me’, scored with subtle brass behind the vocal lines and echoing ambient synth sounds in the extended coda.

‘I See You’ is undoubtedly a product of the xx’s growth, both as a group and as individual musicians. While Smith’s contribution is perhaps the most pronounced change, it says something for the musicianship of Madley-Croft and Sims that they have been able to adapt stylistically and adopt a fresh take on the band’s established sound.


The xx’s third LP ‘I See You’ is out now on Young Turks. TGTF’s extensive previous coverage of the xx is collected back here.

Tags: , , , ,

Leave Your Response

* Name, Email, Comment are Required

About Us

There Goes The Fear is where we tell you about the latest music, gigs, and tours we love and think you should too.

We love music that has its heart on its sleeve, tells a story, swims around our head all day or makes us dance like no-one's watching.

TGTF was edited by Mary Chang, based in Washington, DC.

All MP3s are posted with the permission of the artists or their representatives and are for sampling only. Like the music? Buy it.

RSS Feed   RSS Feed  

Learn More About Us

Privacy Policy

Keep TGTF online for years to come!
Donate here.